Tuesday December 2, 2008 - 22:32:36 GMT
Share This Story
Black Swan Capital - www.blackswantrading.com
Can you say 1% Treasury Bond Yield?
â˘ Russiaâs central bank probably doubled spending of foreign reserves to defend the ruble from its biggest weekly plunge against the euro in more than four years. (Bloomberg)
(Chart unavailable in text format.)
â˘ The Canadian dollar recovered some ground versus the U.S. dollar on Tuesday but remained range-bound and at risk of pressure from falling oil prices and political uncertainty in Canada. (Reuters)
"The great question is whether the government will succeed in reinstilling the inflationary spirit of reckless abandon in American lenders and borrowers. Debasement is what the authorities are driving toward. Itâs why they keep inventing new [lending] facilities.â
FX Trading â Can you say 1% Treasury Bond Yield?
The Fedâs announcement that it will start buying Treasury bonds, along with everyone else in the world it seems, pushes the Fed into official Quantitative Easing (QE) territory.
(Chart unavailable in text format.)
A recent article, dated October 10th, carried in the Financial Times by Graham Turner, from GFC Economics, helps explain why this was needed [our emphasis]:
âBut, as we saw in Japan, that may well not be enough. The recapitalisation of banks in 1998 is often cited as a successful intervention that turned the corner for Japan. That is not true. The stock market did not hit its lows until April 2003.
âThe tide only turned when long term interest rates were pegged down at low levels too, with the Bank of Japan buying government debt. This is the essence of quantitative easing. The Ministry of Finance was also allowed by the US administration to intervene in the currency markets and drive the yen down.
Clearly the latter is not an option for the world economy. But driving down both short and long term rates is a far better policy weapon than the current stream of government initiatives, which will wreak havoc with the public sector finances.
Todayâs partial recapitalisations of banks are not the answer because they will accelerate the slide into a debt trap. In the absence of radical monetary easing, the increased government borrowing to fund quasi nationalisations will ensure bond yields remain elevated. We are repeating many of the mistakes made by successive Japanese governments during the 1990s. They allowed the JGB curve to steepen and that delayed the much needed decline in borrowing costs. It would be better if governments in the West simply nationalised struggling banks outright. But even this still has to be funded through quantitative easing, otherwise, there will be classic crowding out as idenitified by Keynes.
âIndeed, Japan saw its public sector debt burden soar from 65% to 175% of GDP between 1990 and 2005. This increase in public spending was not Keynesian. For much of this period before the BoJ started buying government debt aggressively, it caused bond yields to remain elevated relative to short rates. Lending rates did not fall quickly enough, and Japan became embedded in a cycle of debt deflation.â
So maybe there is a plan behind Helicopter Benâs seemingly ongoing debasement.
We get asked often why this weight of dollars thrown onto the market wonât push the dollar down the proverbial rat hole. And our answer, right or wrong, is that this is a relative game. And because the US banking system, as bad as it is, still lacks the exposure of the dollarâs main competitors.
âNotwithstanding all the problems in the US banking system, the size of banksâ balance sheet is much smaller in the US than in many other countries. For example, total bank liabilities are around 650% of GDP for Switzerland, 430% for the UK, 320% for the Euroland, 150% for Japan and 85% for the US. Investors should keep this fact in mind,â writes Morganâs Stephen Jen. [Our emphasis]
But what about the return of inflation, wonât that be bad for the dollar? Well it might! But given the increased potential for major debt default to come, i.e. high yield corporate bonds and EM countries, the major deleveraging phase seems far from over. And as we know, consumers are finally getting scarred enough to start saving and the banks are still too damaged (or frightened) to lend. Thus the money multiplier is plunging. This should keep inflation at bay for a whileâdeflation is the real concern now. And news global guru favorite China is in trouble only adds to this concern. After all, China was supposed to be the White Knight to ride in on its massive reserve horse to save the rest of us heathens. That ainât going to happen is our bet!
Again from Mr. Jen at Morgan [our emphasis]:
âWe looked at the trajectories for M2 of Japan and the US. During Japanâs QE period, its M2 expanded from around 125% of GDP to more than 140%. In the US, M2 has expanded from 53% to 57% of GDP since September. While the latter is a sharp surge, M2/GDP is not substantially higher than it was during 2003, when the Fed drove the FFR towards 1.00%. Indeed, most of the surge in the figure comes from the anticipated sharp drop in 4Q nominal GDP. To summarise, while base money has increased dramatically (by 34% since August), M2 has grown by only 2.7%.
âThe reason for this, of course, is that the âmoney multiplierâ (MM) has collapsed, reflecting a severe breakdown in the ability and the willingness of the bank and non-bank entities in the US to intermediate capital to the extent they had done prior to the crisis. The collapse in the US MM is significantly more severe than in the case of Japan, during which time Japanâs MM fell from around 10 times the size of the BoJâs balance sheet to around 6.5 times (a fall of 35%). In the US in the last two months, we have seen the US MM falling from more than 9 to around 7 (down 22%).â
So, the US money multiplier collapsing faster than Japanâs didâŚhmmm. Maybe that explains why Helicopter Ben is breaking out all the tools in his box.
Q: Quick thoughts on the implications of the Chinese yuan shift that is showing up on the charts? Bullish/bearish for what? Bonds? Stocks?
(Chart unavailable in text format.)
A: We think it is bullish for bonds (not corporate) and bearish for stocks. It portends big problems for China. Hot money is likely running out for cover; a bit of âChinese capitulation,â so to speak. We think that is what sparked yesterdayâs moves higher in bonds and stocks. We think it will be ongoing as China spirals downward beyond expectations.
Black Swan Capital LLC
Forex Trading News
Daily Forex Market News
Forex news reports can be found on the forex research
headlines page below. Here you will find real-time forex market news reports
provided by respected contributors of currency trading information. Daily forex
market news, weekly forex research and monthly forex news features can be found
Real-time forex market news reports and features providing
other currency trading information can be accessed by clicking on any of the
headlines below. At the top of the forex blog page you will find the latest
forex trading information. Scroll down the page if you are looking for less
recent currency trading information. Scroll to the bottom of fx blog headlines
and click on the link for past reports on forex. Currency world news reports
from previous years can be found on the left sidebar under "FX Archives."